| 
Charles McCann v State Hospital Board for Scotland | 
|   | 
  | 
| Issue:  | 
Whether a ban on smoking in hospitals breached Arts 8 and/or 14 ECHR. | 
|   | 
  | 
| Court:  | 
Court of Session, Inner House; | 
|   | 
  | 
| Reference:    | 
P1265/12 | 
|   | 
  | 
| Neutral Citation:    | 
[2014] CSIH 71 | 
|   | 
  | 
| Judge(s):  | 
Lord Carloway (the Lord Justice Clerk), Lady Paton, Lord Brodie | 
|   | 
  | 
| Date:  | 
12 August 2014 |